FBG Project D-063
• Source: Yost
Mutual Life Insurance Building
- San Francisco
- Contract: Sep 1906
- Architect: Nathan Blaisdell
(for both original and reconstructed building)
- Demolished in 1919
The Mutual Life Insurance of New York company owned the building at the southeast corner of Sansome and California and occupied most of the upper floors, with the Canadian Bank of Commerce occupying the basement and first floor. By all accounts, the earthquake did minimal damage to the steel-framed 7-story stone and brick building… but there were only hours to make that judgment, as the following fire completely gutted the building. (Something that appears to have been true for most of the destruction; thousands of buildings that might have been salvageable after the quake were burned to the ground.)
The building, as shown at right, was left gutted but standing and largely structurally intact. Mutual Life finally decided to demolish the badly damaged upper floors and rebuild on top of the lower two. FBG was hired to do the demolition based on their very low bid for the work, and they removed the upper floors over a period of three months, while the Canadian Bank of Commerce continued its business in the ground floor and basement.
Exactly what rebuilding was done after the demoltion, and the configuration of the building between 1907 and 1919, has not been determined. It is also not clear if FBG did the reconstruction. The only clues that they did are Edna Yost's cryptic reference to “the Canadian Commerce Building” as one of the San Francisco project, in a separate description from the demolition of the “Mutual Life Insurance building,” and that no other contractor or note of construction has been found.
The building continued to be used by the Mutual Life Insurance company, with another bank as tenant in the ground floors, until the rebuilt structure was demolished in 1919 to rebuild the space with the 15-story Balfour Building, which still stands.
- Note that this building is sometimes confused with another victim of the San Francisco disaster, the Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Building. In otherwise undifferentiated photos, the PMLI building can be identified by its rectangular shape, significant structural damage and large, square window spaces instead of the smaller, ornate structure of the building under discussion above.
The Fireproofing Expert
Frank Gilbreth took the Mutual Life Building job (the part for demolition, at least) on an extremely low bid of cost plus $2,000, to ensure he'd get the contract. He, and many other builder/engineers, wanted to get their hands on the structure to see how it had survived the double disaster when other buildings had crumbled. He became something of a celebrity, writing a definitive article that was republished in many places, and speaking on the topic for the remainder of his building career.
The Canadian Bank of Commerce
The role of the Canadian Bank of Commerce in these events is both well-documented and frustratingly hard to sort out, from Edna Yost's cryptic note that one of Frank's jobs in SF was the “Canadian Commerce Building” and extending to the uncertainty of where they finally set up new offices.
- Extensively documented
- Yost, p.134, p.142
The building left after FBG's demolition-in-place was rebuilt to an unknown extent and remained until 1919. It was then razed and a new building, known as the Balfour Building, built in its place. This building still stands.
- The Mutual Life Building burning, Apr 19 or 20, 1906:
- SF Chronicle, 27 Apr 1906:
- SF Chronicle, 25 May 1906:
- The Mutual Life Building being dismantled by FBG crews, probably about October, 1906:
- Another view, probably about the same time (from Bricklaying System):
- Real Estate Record & Building Guide, 29 Sep 1906:
- SF Examiner, 14 Oct 1906:
- SF Chronicle, 9 Mar 1907; similar notices in SF Call, Engineering Record and Real Estate Record:
- Noted as case study in CHJ paper.
- Considerable additional archive material available.
In the case study for the CHG paper, I misidentified the location as the northwest corner of Sansome and California and the Bank of California building as the survivor/successor to this one. That is incorrect; Bank of California rebuilt their own building on the northwest corner, and this building's history is entirely on the southeast corner of the intersection.